Arcoat General Contractor Inc. No Longer In Business

General Contractors
Calgary AB T2Y 5H1
Write a Review
Write a Review
General Contractors
Arcoat General Contractor Inc. No Longer In Business
Star Score
StarScore uses a complex algorithm which considers a company’s review ratings, responsiveness, reputation, and recency. Learn more.


This is the average rating based on homeowner reviews.
This indicates how long it's been since the last review.
Low reputation means there has been review tampering or a company request to remove a review. This score is also impacted when we do not have enough information i.e: low number of reviews.
How well a company responds to Service Requests and Reviews.
Reviews by rating (past 12 months)

Reviews for Arcoat General Contractor Inc. No Longer In Business

Average customer rating:
0 10 (2 reviews)

Sort by

fg in Calgary
fg in Calgary
5 reviews Calgary, AB

Complete Condo Renovation

<b> UPDATE: Carlos has now started a new company under the name of RedefineYYC. At least two of the pictures on the website were done under another company name. </b>

This is his pattern - do shoddy work, close down the company so that he doesn't have to be responsible for it (I was told that it was a business decision) and then start up under a new name.

This review is for work done by Carlos under the company name of PBIC, which is owned by the same owner as PSE (Protective Surface Enterprises).

I am posting here as it was Carlos's work that is to be reflected. It is a similar story as the other reviews posted.

I hired Carlos after getting multiple quotes and references. He had done other work in my condo building and appeared to be reputable. He had started doing work under the banner of PBIC instead of Arcoat. I did not understand till later why.

The scope of the work was a complete got the condo literally from ceiling to floor. It included, but was not limited to, the following:

– drop ceilings with knockdown texture and pot lights throughout
– a new kitchen which included removal of the wall and re-positioning of electrical
- New flooring, which was either laminate or tiling, throughout
– new bathrooms, which included new vanities new toilets and in the master bath a new walk-in shower
– New baseboards and doors
– new electrical switches and outlets
– painting throughout
– Other miscellaneous items

Carlos' work was random at first. He said that everything would be done in three weeks. I was doubtful as I had run into time overruns before. Chalked this up to contractor talk. He would show up randomly, his crew was there more regularly. He was random and in his communications , he would tell you what you'd want to hear. When I asked him what would get done in a particular day or week he would tell me and it never would.

He always put you on a rush timeline insisting that you had to do something i.e. pick out tiles or doors and then would not do anything about it for a week.

Separately, I was also having a split air conditioning installed by a separate company. This involved the pulling of an electrical permit. I had told Carlos that I also wanted a permit pulled for the rest of the electrical in the condo as a new drop ceiling was put in and pot lights were being installed throughout.

The other conversations had been cordial, even if they weren't conducive to getting lots done. When it came to the electrical permit, everything took a turn. It turns out that he did not quote for the electrical permit in the original cost as he did not think it was necessary. I insisted that it was. It was a good thing that I did because unbeknownst to me, when the inspection came for the AC, the city inspector noted that there was no other permit pulled for the rest of the electrical. As a result, and non-permit was put against the property. What that meant was that I would not be able to sell it unless I got a permit. The city inspector actually took the time to track me down. He did not have any of my contact information as I'm not the one who pulled the other permit. He explained what had happened and that he'd actually told Carlos that he needed to get a permit, which ironically was at the same time that I told him to get a permit.

When confronted with this information, Carlos did what he normally did and did a lot of talking. I was not letting him do only the talking. I insisted on a permit and that this matter be cleared up right away.

He did get a permit and the renovation continue to drag on. The next issue was around the shower. It was a walk in shower with a bench. I insisted that Carlos waterproof the shower basin. He kept arguing with me on that. In the end, it only took 15 minutes. I said why are you going to argue with a customer over something that takes you 15 minutes to do. I specifically said to him that no work was to continue on the shower until he and I had a conversation. He chose to ignore that. After the renovations were done, and I was ostensibly allowed to live in the condo while the touch ups were being done, I started using the shower. Within a day, many threads of the black mesh on the floor of the shower started popping up. When I asked the tile setter about this, he said that he had not finished grouting nor sealing the shower. When I asked Carlos about it, he claimed that it had been done by someone else. I also pointed out the back of the shower that seem to slow down and water was pooling. Carlos said that it would get sorted. This would be disproven as within a few months so much water was pooling at the back went taking a shower that the grout started coming up.

When it came to the kitchen, in which Carlos clearly had no experience installing, he stated that the contract only included the installation of the boxes, meaning the cupboards. The doors and drawers were extra. This was the first time I heard of this and ended up having to pay someone else to do this. Just his way of trying to recoup some money.

It was just about done when there was an incident with the plumber. Carlos, who is supposed to be my general contractor, allowed the plumber to do shoddy work and be disrespectful towards me. It was at that point but I insisted on speaking to Carlos' supervisor.

The supervisor came in and mediated the situation. I was presented with a final bill which was close to $10 000 over our original agreement. I refuse to pay the vast majority of it as none of these extra charges, with the exception of one, had been agreed to.

About a month after the renovations were done in the final payment was made, a crack appeared in my ceiling in the master bedroom. This is a brand new drop-down ceiling. Some people out to fix it and only made it look worse. When I asked again for it to be fixed, I was told the company had ceased operations and would no longer be doing any work. So much for my one-year guarantee.

Since then, more cracks of appeared in ceiling. Additionally, my shower over which there was much discussion, has major grout coming out as reported on evenly and it pools at the back corner.

Having a guarantee means nothing. There are many other stories like this. Carlos does not hold up his end of the bargain. It appears the pattern is to work under a company and then close it as long as it's no longer sustainable for you and don't feel like having any integrity.

Update 2: I had some other electrical work done. As a result of this, it turned out that the pot lights were not hard wired rather, a plug was run to plug it in. The electrician had never seen anything like this.

Was this review helpful?
Andrew C in Calgary
Andrew C in Calgary
3 reviews Calgary, AB


Arcoat was contracted to perform renovations on the home that we purchased. During the course of renovations, faulty plumbing was installed in one of the upstairs bathrooms and subsequently the leak caused water damage and mould to develop in one of the lower level rooms. The owner Carlos, was notified of the issue and they came to repair the faulty plumbing lines but refused to acknowledge the water and mould damage despite clear evidence of the issue. A mould inspector was then hired to come and perform testing which confirmed what we already knew. A report with the results was then given to the contractor but they still continued to refuse acknowledgement of the issue. We ended up paying out of pocket to remediate the issue and repair the damaged room, some of which was performed by myself to save costs. We then sought legal counsel on the matter and offered to settle the issue out of court, but the contractor continued to deny responsibility for the issue -- dodging phone calls, emails and letters from our lawyer's office for weeks, then months. We ended up suing them in court and won the lawsuit but then came to find out that the company closed their doors, leaving us with no recourse for the damages. Completely dishonest and irresponsible, this is the kind of company that gives general contractors a negative stereotype. Would advise anyone refrain from working with Carlos in the future in whatever shape or form he ends up in next.

**Update: We have now discovered more issues with this home during the renovation process that was performed by Arcoat / PBIC / Redefine. The home that we purchased has an open concept after removal of several walls during the course of renovations. However, the load bearing walls that were removed were then not properly supported leading to structural issues with the house. We had this confirmed by an engineering firm and have had to undertake extensive costs to remediate the issue out of pocket. Completely irresponsible behaviour by this company, made worse by the fact that they built a stub wall to simulate the look of a support beam, which in fact was not supported whatsoever. I cannot stress enough that this company is dangerous to work with and will put you and the occupants of your home at risk.

Review has 2 previous versions
Was this review helpful?
The reviews on this page are the subjective opinion of the Author and not of HomeStars Inc.
Company profile information is not moderated by HomeStars. Ask the contractor to verify before hiring.
Looking for General Contractors pros in Calgary?