Like most other reviews say, Home Depot/HD roofing comes in higher in price, but you get what you pay for, including a transferable warranty to the next home owner. Also, the chances of Home Depot going under in the next 25+ years is slim so it gave me piece of mind. On the day of, the guys that showed up were from Katin Roofing, which is fine I guess since the contract states that Home Depot/HD Roofing would outsource the job to one of their trusted agents. Overall, they were friendly, quick and did a good job to the specs agreed. Cleanup was good, but could have been slightly better.