Old Shack Renovations

Formerly O'Brien and Son's Carpentry and General Contractor
Carpenters
55 Glenabbey Drive Courtice ON L1E 2B5
Write a Review
Write a Review
HomeStars
Carpenters
Old Shack Renovations
Star Score
StarScore uses a complex algorithm which considers a company’s review ratings, responsiveness, reputation, and recency. Learn more.

78%

This is the average rating based on homeowner reviews.
This indicates how long it's been since the last review.
Low reputation means there has been review tampering or a company request to remove a review. This score is also impacted when we do not have enough information i.e: low number of reviews.
How well a company responds to Service Requests and Reviews.
Reviews by rating (past 12 months)

Reviews for Old Shack Renovations

Average customer rating:
8.6 10 (18 reviews)

Sort by

Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Toronto, ON
0/10

bathroom reno, the worst service ever, excuses, late, over promised, under delivered, did not show up & avoided calls

I had hired Bill previously for some framing and drywall which was satisfactory. He made out as if they do all sorts of renovations, so when it came time for my upstairs reno I called for a quote.

The quote was reasonable but now I know "what is cheap is dear..."
He said it was a 4-5 day job (one day reno, one day tile floor, one day tile tub surround and then two days to paint, grout and put back vanity and toilet)
It sounded reasonable, we agreed on a price and I would supply the materials. The price was for labour only.
Day 1 - (monday) he showed up and put down paper but no drop cloths, he stapled plastic to the door frame (I was not happy about him not using tape) He removed the vanity, toilet, placed the drawers on my white lacquered desk with nothing underneath. There was no care to how items were scattered all over the place. He did not protect my staircase at all, there was dust from the demo everywhere. He showed up alone, I was surprised how he would be able to remove all the items by himself. He asked me for some money that day, even though I paid for all the supplies and he had done not even 50% of the work. I gave him $700 cash.

Day 2 (Tuesday)- I called to see if he was at the house as he did not show up. First he said it was his truck, then I called to check later and he said it was a family matter. Needles to say he was a no show

Day 3 - (wednesday) he showed up with his son in law and they tried as they could to catch up. Bill locked himself out of the house and had to come collect my key from me. More time spent not on the job, but screwing around. He replaced the tub and said he did a tub test. He replaced the shower plumbing in the kit I had. I did pick up the wrong kit, but instead of letting me know during the day when I could do something about it he sent me an email at night. Pieces from the box were taken out and scattered.

Day 4 - (wednesday) late because of his truck again??? I had gone out to get the correct shower diverted kit. I had to go back to the store 2 x as he went ahead and installed the diverter from the kit, even though he was unsure it was the correct one. He started to tile the tub surround and when I came home I was again surprised to see he used torn paper from the box rather than use plastic spacers. Really, how much are the spacers? He was cheaping out at my expense and the tiles were crooked. I would have gladly picked up the plastic spacers had I know he did not have enough. The tile was a large subway tile. He said he was going to lay down the floor to dry fit it. There were tools all over the 48 square foot bathroom, it really should have been all cleared out first and then lay out the tiles to install properly. When I took a second look he had laid mortar under the tiles, they were all twisted and uneven spaced and uneven levels as he had stepped on the tiles leaving the bathroom.
Day 5 - Friday - this was supposed to be the last day but he was no where near finished. When I came back the tub was tiled 80%, floor was 70% . All the perimeter needed to be laid. Meanwhile the staircase was trashed with all the activity up and down, it was scuffed as materials had been dragged along the treads. There was more dust. He used mortar rather than tile glue so it was a haze of white dust.
Day 6- (Saturday) I finally talked to Bill and said I was unhappy with the quality of the work and that the tiles needed to be replaced as they were different levels. I needed a real timeline from him to when the job was to be finished. A proper schedule, no more coming late, I wanted to know what tasks were to be done on what day so I could have it all finished. The tiles needed to be ordered from Montreal so to stay on schedule new materials needed to be ordered ASAP. He agreed that the job was not the best he would pay for the new materials.

Day 7 (Sunday) - he did not show up for work, I called him 4 x and text him 2x. He arrived at 2:30pm to pick up his tools and leave the job. The house was a total mess. The bathroom was unfinished, he left the place with not so much as a thought to even try and help clean up, sweep, or wipe down anything. He promised he would pay me back the money I gave him and the supplies he used, he said he would answer my calls. I questioned his word as he was letting me down and did not answer all morning.

I had several other tilers & contractors come by and they all agreed the work was shoddy. He should never laid the floor until everything else was done. The brand new tub was not covered with any plywood to protect it, so there was mortar blotches on the covering that could cause scratching. Nothing was straight, everything was wonky. Every single contractor agreed everything had to be removed and started from scratch, nothing could be salvaged.

After several calls, texts and emails Bill sent me an email agreeing to pay me back the sum of materials used, my cash deposit and the cost for the new demo. We had an agreed repayment schedule. I was frustrated that the project was taking so long as it would be another full week without a bath/shower and in the meantime I had to pay the new trades.

Day 14 - (sunday) 2 of my new contractors were carrying the 39 inch vanity back and we could see there was a large scuff on the side. Bill must have scuffed the vanity when he removed all by himself. It is a really heavy piece. I sent him a pic and he said he would have his cabinetmaker guy quote to repair. That was on the Monday - all week I never heard back.

On the Tuesday there was leaking on my kitchen ceiling. The tub was missing the P trap, he did not hook it up, nor did he mention to anyone the plumbing was incomplete. He also did not correctly hook up the tub spout. Everyone knows you test the plumbing before you tile.
When the deadline Saturday came to make the first payment, no surprise he did make it, nor did he get in touch to tell me he was not able to make the payment. This easy 5 day renovation has turned into the worst experience. He has not gotten back to me after many phone calls, emails and texts. I have no choice now but to take him to small claims court.

OLD SHACK is aptly named, cause that is how my property was left, looking like an old shack

PLEASE PLEASE DO NOT HIRE THIS INCOMPETENT CONTRACTOR

NB in the photo below I placed the mdf on the tub to protect from further damage

Was this review helpful? Yes No
North York Homeowner
North York Homeowner
3 reviews Toronto, ON
10/10

Preparation for new kitchen

In the fall of 2016 I had the fortunate opportunity to hire Bill and Andrew to; restructure kit & dining room openings, install laminate floor, new doors, trim, baseboard, kit exhaust & reface stairs.
I'm happy to report that their skillful workmanship changed the look and feel of my home. They were calm, patient, respectful and easy to be around. Bottom line: Bill and Andrew did a great job!

Was this review helpful?
Private User
Private User
Private User reviews Toronto, ON
0/10

Service disappointing. Doesn't finish, has more excuses than we have ever heard! Wont communicate. Avoid this company.

Dors not show up when expected, doesnt call with an explanation. Repeatedly.
Extremely u nreliable, more excuses than Anyone can believe. Tried to work with him but you can never reach him

Review has 1 previous version
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful?
rstm.miles in Brighton
rstm.miles in Brighton
1 review Brighton, ON
10/10

Bedroom In Brighton

Bill and Andrew really put together a great space for our son to call his own when he's home. Thank you so very much!

Was this review helpful? Yes No
Bonnie
Bonnie
1 review Newcastle, ON
8/10

Basement Storage Room

Billy, Andrew and the gang did a great job. I love the shelving and can't believe what a difference this has made to the basement.

Was this review helpful?
jpeters in Courtice
jpeters in Courtice
1 review Courtice, ON
10/10

Water Damage Repair

When the water damage was discovered and we placed a call to Bill, the response time was incredible! He and Andrew pulled up, assessed the situation and jumped immediately into action. They had already worked a full day, yet didn't complain once and worked into the evening to complete the job. Amazing work ethic as well. Thanks again, guys!

Was this review helpful? Yes No
Andrea in Whitby
Andrea in Whitby
1 review Whitby, ON
10/10

Frame and finish garage and outdoor living room

Bill and Andrew built our new garage from the bottom up. It turned out great. They worked every day until the whole Job was finished. It was refreshing to work with people who looked at our ideas but also offered some really great and creative ones of their own. We're thrilled with the work they did!

Was this review helpful?
Rossland garden dental in Ajax
Rossland garden dental in Ajax
1 review Ajax, ON
10/10

Flooring

We were extremely pleased with Bill and Andrew, they were punctual and very professional! The work they did was incredible, our office looks so much better!! Our patients complement us on it all the time. their prices are reasonable and they even fixed our front office door at no extra cost!!! Would highly recommend Old Shack Renovations and if we Need more work we know who to call!! Thanks Bill and Andrew was a pleasure!!!

Was this review helpful?
The reviews on this page are the subjective opinion of the Author and not of HomeStars Inc.

More about Old Shack Renovations

Choosing a great contractor is the most important decision required when making your dream home become a reality. Old Shack Renovation boasts 25+ years of home renovation experience ranging from simple and small fixes of problem areas in your home to large scale projects and additions. From finishing your basement ...
Company profile information is not moderated by HomeStars. Ask the contractor to verify before hiring.
Looking for Carpenters pros in Toronto?