Lopsided tiles, crooked doorways, really just half- assed and looking at it now I feel ripped off. Other trades that have come in to do additional work have commented on the sloppy job as well.
A few days after he left and were able to put the appliances back, we realized the fridge would no longer fit in its slot. Dave's solution to this was to take apart my fridge hinge covers and try to remove the feet (not possible)
I see now I should have had them remove everything, not let them just chip the tiles off and reuse the cement and wire mesh. I feel he took advantage of the fact I really knew nothing about tile work and got away with doing a bad job.
He is really very nice and friendly and I just trusted him to do a good job. Everybody I spoke to about him had good things to say, so I'm not sure what went so wrong with this project.