Birnie Thos R & Sons Ltd

Plumbing
Hamilton ON L8E
Write a Review
Write a Review

HomeStars  >  Plumbing in Carlisle  >  Birnie Thos R & Sons Ltd  >  Sump Pump Replacement
Tim in Niagara falls
Tim in Niagara falls
1 review Niagara Falls, ON
8/10

Sump Pump Replacement

After reading client testimonials on this site, chose this place to do my repair. At first, I believed this was a very costly mistake, but the company made good on an error.

The plumber arrived on time. He went through the diagnostic work of cutting the pipe and determining that indeed the sump pump was broken. He explained to me that it would cost about $600 to install a sump pump that they supplied or have me get a sump pump and pay $300. I thought this was reasonable (and it was nice for him to allow me to run out and get a cheaper replacement pump), so I headed out to Lowes to get materials while he did some prep work and prepared paperwork. When I got back with the pump, he said that he would also need to replace "a little pipe". I thought "obviously", since the pump type was switching from a pedestal to a submersible, and he cut the pipe to see what the problem was. He then presented me with the estimate for $640 + taxes -- $292 for the sump pump replacement and $348 for the pipe work.

At this point, I had a decision to make: sign the estimate (well after the work was done) or have a confrontation over the charges that may end up in shoddy workmanship or leaving me to call someone else to do the repair. This is why a company must always present an estimate up front and abide by that estimate. Both the customer and the vendor are at risk when the statement of work isn't provided "up front".

So, all in all, I felt deceived. I was told it would be $300 to replace the pump, and when I got back with the pump, there was an additional charge of $350 to replace pipe that should be part of the sump pump replacement work.

All in all, the plumber spent 75 minutes of work and charged $640 of labour to replace this and a $10 piece of pipe. I felt ripped off.

I received a followup call from the company to ask about their service, which was a nice surprise. I told them that the cost was too high and they informed me that someone would call me back.

Someone did. We talked about the job that was performed and my experience with the plumber. Although the work done was quite satisfactory, I expressed my view that there was an error with the charge. The company asked me what I felt would make things right. I asked them to remove the charge for the pipe installation as I felt like the charge for that was dishonest.

The company respresentative agreed and removed the charge the pipe replacement charge ($348).

Because the company was willing to reason and admitted that the billing was a mistake, I can now recommend them to my friends and family. Thanks for restoring my faith in the industry.

Approximate cost of services:
$395.00
Was this review helpful?

Previous versions of this review:

Tim in Niagara falls
Tim in Niagara falls
1 review Niagara Falls, ON
1/10

Sump Pump Replacement

After reading client testimonials on this site, chose this place to do my repair. What a costly mistake.

The plumber arrived on time. He went through the diagnostic work of cutting the pipe and determining that indeed the sump pump was broken. He explained to me that it would cost about $600 to install a sump pump that they supplied or have me get a sump pump and pay $300. I thought this was reasonable, so I headed out to Lowes to get a pipe and cinder block while he dug out the muck that was causing the issue and prepared the paperwork. When I got back with the pump, he said that he would also need to replace "a little pipe". I thought "obviously", since the pump type was switching from a pedestal to a submersible, and he cut the pipe to see what the problem was. He then presented me with the estimate for $640 + taxes -- $292 for the sump pump replacement and $348 for the pipe work.

He said that he would be at about an hour or so. I signed the estimate, as the work of diagnostic was finished and I really didn't have a choice as the primary work had already begun. He was finished 30 minutes later and spent 15 minutes afterwards in his truck doing paperwork.

So, all in all, it's deceptive. I was told it would be $300 to replace the pump, and when I got back with the pump, there was an additional charge of $350 to replace pipe that should be part of the sump pump replacement work. When you replace a sump pump, there will always be the need to adjust and replace pipes to fit. In the case of changing from a pedestal pump to a submersible (as the technican advised) of course pipe needs to be replaced. There should not be a charge for this.

All in all, the plumber spent 75 minutes of work and charged $640 of labour to replace this and a $10 piece of pipe.

On top of that, I received a followup call after the appointment. I explained to the CSR that the cost was too high. She told me that a manager would call me back. He never did.

I do not believe that the $348.36 charge to replace pipe is reasonable. Replacing pipe is part of sump pump replacement work (which was charged separately and was reasonable). This work was explained to me after the fact and was not part of the original estimate.

Use a different company.

Approximate cost of services:
$723.00